Is there a link between heated political rhetoric and acts of violence? I’ve been wrestling with that question ever since the carnage in Tucson.
Some commentators and politicians have been bending over backwards to appear moderate, urging us not to point fingers. And clearly, the person firing the gun caused the deaths and the injuries, not Sarah Palin or the National Rifle Association or the store that sold the gun or the politicians who oppose stricter gun-control laws.
Still, the question has nagged at me; political discourse has just become so ugly. There was a time when Republicans and Democrats got along, despite their philosophical differences.
During the 2008 presidential campaign, people took guns to rallies and hinted at violence. During the health-care debate, people were angry, hostile. Someone threw a rock through the window of one of the regional offices of both Gabrielle Giffords and Rochester’s Louise Slaughter. Slaughter and others said there had been threats against them and their family members. Palin’s office says she’s been getting numerous death threats.
On talk radio and on the internet, the insults and the hostility flow.
Can we really say that this climate contributed nothing to the tragedy in Tucson? Is there no connection?
Rochester Institute of Technology criminal justice professor John Klofas frequently cautions me about drawing easy conclusions, stressing the importance of research, so I called him with my questions. His answer:
Of course there’s a connection.
First to the research: There haven’t been a lot of studies on the impact of rhetoric, Klofas says. The hard research has been on the connection between violent acts and “media violence” - not just entertainment but also news coverage. The findings: violence in the media doesn’t affect most people. It doesn’t affect young people who live in stable, structured homes. But for young people with no support system, there’s “a pretty significant impact,” Klofas says. And people with mental-health problems are a “suggestive population,” he says.