The closure of the Key Food supermarket at 5661 Riverdale Ave. is drawing renewed attention to how long-standing building violations and deferred maintenance at the Skyview Shopping Center property went unresolved while one of North Riverdale’s most relied-upon grocery stores continued operating.
In the days before it shuttered on Dec. 16, shelves stood bare and clearance signs advertised 20 percent off remaining items — even on top of existing sale prices, a last hurrah for shoppers as a neighborhood anchor for those living nearby.
For many residents, the loss removes one of the few supermarkets that balanced walkability and parking. The shutdown now forces residents, particularly seniors, to travel farther for necessities in an area where options have steadily narrowed.
“Many of our senior citizens must walk the hills and valleys of Riverdale, some of which do not have sidewalks, in order to shop here,” Thomas Maguire, a nearby resident, noted. “They will now have to take a bus to 235th Street, down to Broadway or up to Yonkers in order to do their basic shopping.”
Many described the closure as more than an isolated event, but as a symbol of the latest chapter in more than a decade of instability at the site.
“This has created a blight which affects the lives and the property values of everyone that lives here,” Maguire urged.
While this week’s shutdown was announced with little notice, records from the New York City Department of Buildings, or DOB, show conditions inside the store had been cited repeatedly for years.
According to the city’s Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, inspectors cited the store’s operator for “failure to maintain the building in a code-compliant manner” on April 23, 2025, issuing a Severity Class 2 violation.
Violation notes state that inspectors observed “defective ceiling tile inside with evidence of water stains due to water leak,” as well as a “defective ceiling throughout store with missing ceiling tiles throughout.” The official also documented a “bucket w/ hoses attached to collect water” during the same visit. The associated penalty totaled $1,280, and the DOB reports the violation remains open.
Those conditions closely mirror an earlier violation issued five years back. In that case, inspectors cited “missing, broken and water-damaged acoustical ceiling tiles at various locations of supermarket” and ordered that the conditions be “repaired and replaced immediately.”
That violation resulted in a $625 penalty. Yet, Key Food remained unresolved as the store continued operating.
Several residents told The Press those conditions were visible long before the supermarket's demise. Several described stained ceiling tiles scattered throughout sporting brown water stains.
Mary Devlin, who shopped at the store weekly, said the closure is especially heartbreaking because of the workers she’s known there for years.
“It clearly really needs remodeled and updated,” she said. “But the people there – the staff – are really good people, and they’ve been doing the best they can.”
Devlin continued, adding employees regularly went out of their way to help customers.
“The woman in the meat department wrapped a special pack of salmon for me,” she recalled. “The kid in dairy ordered yogurts that my husband liked. I’ve heard older people come in and call them by name. It’s a real sense of community.”
Beyond access, the closure creates consequences for those who rely on the store for steady income. Dozens of employees are expected to lose their jobs with no more than two weeks of advance notice.
“Over 40 employees will abruptly lose their jobs during the holiday season, which is both heartbreaking and cruel,” said Female Fight Club Owner Johanna Edmonson, who wrote to the plaza’s management, urging an effort to prevent long-term vacancy.
“We’re already struggling with too many vacant storefronts in the area,” she said. “We want to prevent Key Food from becoming another empty space for years to come.”
In addition to the ceiling violations, the property carries roughly $14,000 in civil penalties, according to the DOB NOW online portal.
A summons from the city for those violations listed respondents Shopwell Inc. and KF Braun Management, with the latter owning multiple storefronts nearby.
Years of outreach from residents to Trader Joe’s have long gone unanswered, but elected officials have recently renewed the effort.
Assemblymember Jeffrey Dinowitz and Councilmember Eric Dinowitz sent joint letters to Braun Management and to Trader Joe’s urging swift action to secure a replacement supermarket.
“Key Food leaving this shopping center will result in many people now having extra challenges when it comes to food shopping,” the officials wrote. “Both representatives would like to address any challenges as early as possible.”
As the lights go dark at Key Food, residents say the unanswered question is not only what replaces the store, but how years-old violations were allowed to persist as conditions worsened and whether the same pattern will repeat.
KF Braun did not respond to requests for comment.