A rabbi who formerly served at the Riverdale Jewish Center, is calling for moral clarity amid Israel’s military campaign in Gaza in an open letter.
Rabbi Dr. Irving “Yitz” Greenberg was among 85 Orthodox Jewish leaders to sign the statement titled “A Call for Moral Clarity, Responsibility, and a Jewish Orthodox Response in the Face of the Gaza Humanitarian Crisis.” Published on Aug. 18, it comes nearly two years after the start of the Israel-Hamas War.
On Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attacked Israel, killing 1,200 people, most of whom were civilians, and taking 250 others hostage. In response, Israel launched a ground and air operation that has now killed more than 60,000 Palestinians, according to a July 26 update from the Palestinian Ministry of Health.
The United Nations-backed panel of food experts announced famine in Gaza City for the first time on Aug. 22, calling it “man-made.” On Aug. 27, Reuters reported Israel asked the panel to retract the report, calling it “deeply flawed.”
The 600-word “Call for Moral Clarity” repeatedly condemned Hamas but urged Israel to assume “its share of the responsibility for the profound suffering of Gaza’s civilian population,” prevent further harm in the region, and uphold traditional Jewish values.
The letter was written by Rabbi Yosef Blau, a former religious leader at Yeshiva University in Manhattan, who circulated it to other rabbis.
Some, including 92-year–old Greenberg, were members of Torat Chayim, a group that promotes progressive, Torah-based values.
It opens by stating the humanitarian crisis in Gaza is one of the most severe in recent history. While Hamas has “shown a cynical disregard” for Palestinians, Israel’s two-year military campaign has “devastated Gaza.” The text cited the rising death toll and halt of humanitarian aid.
“We affirm that Hamas’s sins and crimes do not relieve the government of Israel of its obligations to make whatever efforts are necessary to prevent mass starvation,” the letter said.
Greenberg lived in Riverdale for 60 years before moving to Jerusalem. As a rabbi, author, and teacher he became a prominent figure locally and beyond.
“The letter was primarily to people in Israel or the Israeli government who wanted to do a harsher policy, and to people in the religious community who … out of anger, feel you can violate democracy and rights of others,” he told The Press.
In the 1960s and 1970s, Greenberg was a congregational rabbi at the Riverdale Jewish Center and co-founded the Salanter Akiba Riverdale Academy, as well as the National Jewish Center for Learning and Leadership.
He later helped establish the United States Holocaust Museum, serving as chairman in the early 2000s.
The statement also points to faults such as blocking humanitarian convoys under the belief it would lead Hamas to surrender, which instead caused “the deepening of despair.”
According to the letter, anger toward Hamas has turned into suspicion of all Gazans as “future terrorists,” while “extremist settler violence” in the West Bank has caused civilian deaths and forced displacement.
It also criticized Israel Prime Minister Netanyahu, saying his lack of post-war vision has allowed extreme voices in government to advance disturbing proposals, such as “the forced ‘voluntary’ exile of Palestinians from Gaza and the sacrifice of remaining Israeli hostages in the pursuit of an elusive ‘total victory.’”
The remainder of the statement calls for a voice rooted in Jewish values of justice and compassion.
It cites the belief that all people are created “b’tzelem Elokim,” or “in the Divine image,” saying that allowing a population to starve contradicts this teaching.
The letter reemphasizes the obligation to support policies that protect human dignity, provide humanitarian aid when possible, and speak out if government actions conflict with the Torah.
It concludes: “The future of Israel depends not only on its military strength but on its moral clarity. Let us be resounding voices for justice, righteousness, and peace for all people — even and especially in the hardest of times.”
Greenberg also condemned Hamas, while saying extremists who speak in the name of religious Zionism are wrong.
“It’s absolutely clear, no matter what the sins of Hamas, that the Israeli government has a moral responsibility — and from a Jewish point of view — to be concerned about the Palestinians and their hunger, just as much as it would be about any other group,” he said.
After “A Call for Moral Clarity” was published, it drew significant media attention.
Some outlets noted the rarity of Orthodox rabbis speaking out, since they tend to lean politically right-wing. But the article did not express views on the content.
Others disagreed with the stance. An op-ed in the “Jewish News Syndicate” called the letter “shameful” and a public act of “desecration of God’s name.”
On Aug. 25, the Coalition for Jewish Values published a rebuttal letter titled “A Rabbinic Response to a Misguided ‘Call for Moral Clarity,’” with 162 signatures.
“A Rabbinic Response” argued that Hamas, not Israel, is responsible for Gaza’s suffering. It rejected most claims in the original letter, saying it misrepresented the war.
The rebuttal stated: “True moral clarity requires recognizing the root of this crisis is Hamas’s evil intent, and that genuine peace requires the eradication of the threat posed by Hamas.”
Despite pushback, Greenberg said the letter’s message remains unchanged.
“There is important religious rabbinic leadership in the Zionist community who want Israel to have a continuous tradition of minimizing civilian casualties,” he said. “Of treating every human being’s life as precious and infinitely valuable.”