The Riverdale Press logo

Thanksgiving tradition brings hundreds together through decade-long Bronx interfaith partnership

Posted

Forty turkeys and scores of homemade cookies are just some of the festivities bringing hundreds of Bronxites together this Thanksgiving, continuing a holiday tradition that has grown out of a decade-long friendship between two religious congregations.

This November marks 10 years since an interfaith collaboration between Creston Avenue Baptist Church in Fordham Manor and the Conservative Synagogue Adath Israel of Riverdale began a partnership rooted in faith and based on mutual understanding and a shared commitment to serving their neighbors.

Since 2016, the houses of worship have brought congregants together for religious celebrations, conversations about race and antisemitism — including in the wake of the death of George Floyd and after October 7 —and an annual Thanksgiving meal that serves hundreds of people, with Creston Pastor Marcia Stanley telling The Press they fed roughly 700 people last year.

The annual meal, now in its ninth year as a joint undertaking, brings together church and synagogue members, community volunteers, and this year, students from the Ethical Culture Fieldston School who help prepare food, collect clothing in drives and assemble holiday greetings. 

“My favorite part is the coming together,” Stanley said, noting she especially enjoys seeing volunteers from both congregations work side by side in the church kitchen to make sure neighbors have the perfect holiday feast.

The partnership began after the Conservative Synagogue Adath Israel of Riverdale’s Rabbi Barry Dov Katz asked then-city council member Fernando Cabrera, also a pastor, to connect him with a church active in community service, Katz explained. Cabrera introduced him to Stanley, whose congregation already operated a food pantry and soup kitchen.

“It’s really important for people to know the people that they share a borough with,” Katz said.

Their relationship grew beyond charitable work. Members visited each other’s houses of worship, shared sacred music and participated in a model Passover Seder. They also held conversations about racism, antisemitism, immigration and the experiences of their respective communities, including discussions during the Covid-19 pandemic.

Katz recalled a Seder in which participants shared their families’ immigration histories, drawing connections between journeys from the Caribbean, Eastern Europe and North Africa.

“I think it just kind of created a sense of shared humanity,” he said. “Which I think is again what’s really so important these days to be reminded of our shared humanity.”

For Stanley, those exchanges gave congregants opportunities to better understand experiences beyond their own. She said the relationship has continued through joint worship activities, conversations and cooperation around the church’s ongoing food assistance programs.

Thanksgiving, however, remains its most visible collaboration. Creston Avenue Baptist Church has hosted a holiday meal for more than 20 years, well before the synagogue joined the effort. Stanley said lines sometimes stretch around the block, with visitors collecting meals to take home to family members.

Church members cook the sides, including macaroni and cheese, collard greens and sweet potatoes, Stanley said, while CSAIR raises money for turkeys and collects cookies, coats and other donations. Volunteers from both congregations organize the distribution, with children making posters and cards to accompany the food.

Sarah Baglio, a CSAIR member who helps coordinate the drive, said volunteers work in shifts, preparing the space in the morning before an assembly line begins serving meals around noon. Some recipients collect food for family members, while others receive donated coats and clothing.

“It’s all of us coming together on equal footing, doing exactly what we can in service to our community,” Baglio said.

A newer partner, Chef Rose’s Restaurant near West 231st Street and Broadway, is preparing 40 turkeys this year. Owner Rosie Batista, who joined the effort last Thanksgiving, said cooking such a large quantity was an unexpected assignment for her Dominican restaurant, where turkey is not traditionally a holiday staple.

Last year’s 40 turkeys required overnight cooking. This year, Batista plans to flatten the birds before roasting to shorten the process. Preparing them still takes several days of brining, seasoning and marinating.

With food costs rising, Batista said her restaurant and the synagogue’s fundraising efforts are sharing the additional expense. Despite the demands of running a small business, she said participating was never just a financial decision.

“I just felt like it was something that we needed to do,” Batista said. “God put Sarah in our way, and we were like, you know what? Let’s just go. Let’s help and do whatever we can.”

The effort is also drawing younger participants. Baglio, who teaches at Ethical Culture Fieldston School, said sophomores in a school community service group have chosen the project, with plans to collect coats and cookies. CSAIR’s Hebrew school students and neighborhood residents are also baking cookies for the meal.

Baglio said donations of warm clothing, particularly men’s coats, remain welcome, along with contributions toward the turkeys.

For Stanley, the 10th anniversary carries a hope that goes well beyond this year’s holiday. She said she wants future generations to remember this partnership as an example of loving one’s neighbor, and to put that belief into practice.

Creston Avenue Baptist Church, Conservative Synagogue Adath Israel of Riverdale, CSAIR, interfaith partnership, Bronx interfaith collaboration, Thanksgiving meal, Bronx Thanksgiving, Thanksgiving food distribution, Bronx community service, Marcia Stanley, Rabbi Barry Dov Katz, Sarah Baglio, Rosie Batista, Chef Rose’s Restaurant, Ethical Culture Fieldston School, Fernando Cabrera, Riverdale, Fordham Manor, Bronx churches, Bronx synagogues, religious cooperation, interfaith dialogue, religious diversity, shared humanity, food assistance, food pantry, soup kitchen, turkey donations, Thanksgiving turkeys, coat drive, cookie donations, community volunteers, antisemitism, racism, George Floyd, October 7, Passover Seder, holiday food donations, Bronx food insecurity

Comments